Ringo Legal, PLLC Logo

Key Takeaways

  • The program allows public funds to be used for private religious education, potentially raising Establishment Clause concerns regarding the separation of church and state.
  • Private schools receiving voucher funds are not mandated to provide accommodations for students with disabilities under federal laws like IDEA, unlike public schools, which creates an equity gap.
  • The Attorney General's opinion granting the comptroller authority to block schools deemed 'tied to terrorists' raises First Amendment (religious freedom, freedom of association) and due process concerns, especially when the designation is disputed and not federally recognized.
  • The prioritization system for voucher access, based on income and disability, coupled with the lack of guaranteed private school acceptance, introduces public policy questions about equitable access and effectiveness.
Alright, so you know how Texas has been talking about school vouchers? Well, the application period for this new state program just kicked off, and it's a pretty big deal. This isn't just about sending kids to private school; it's got some serious legal and public policy stuff simmering underneath. Basically, the state’s offering up taxpayer dollars for families to use for private school tuition or even homeschooling. Applications are open until March 17th, and the whole thing officially starts up next school year, 2026-27. Here's the kicker: if more people apply than the state has money for – and they’ve set aside a cool $1 billion for this current two-year budget cycle – then some families get prioritized. We’re talking about students with disabilities from lower-income homes, or just lower-income families in general. But even if you meet those criteria, it doesn't guarantee your kid a spot, which is a key thing to remember. The comptroller's office, which is basically the state's money manager, is running this show. They've got a billion dollars to spend by August 2027. But financial experts are already looking at a potential bill of $4.8 billion by 2030. That's a massive jump, and it means future lawmakers are going to be making some big decisions about where this money comes from and who gets it. Now, who can apply? Most Texas families with school-age kids can, even if they're already in private school or homeschooled. If your child is in public school now, you’ll need to unenroll them to join. And you'll need to prove your child is a U.S. citizen or legally living here. Easy enough, right? Not always. When it comes to proving income or disability status for priority, you’re looking at providing IRS forms, Social Security numbers, and specific medical or educational documents. These details really matter because they determine how much funding a family can get and if they’ll even be considered first in line. Speaking of disabilities, this is where some legal implications really stand out. While public schools have federal mandates like the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) to provide specific accommodations for students with special needs, private schools don't. That means even if a child with disabilities qualifies for the higher funding tier – up to $30,000 annually, compared to $10,500 for most private school kids and $2,000 for homeschoolers – there’s no guarantee the private school they choose will provide the services they need. You have to find a private school willing to accept your child and meet those needs. It puts the burden squarely on families to vet these schools, which is a different ballgame than the rights public school students have. To get that top-tier funding for a child with disabilities, families need an Individualized Education Program (IEP). That’s a legal document from a public school system detailing a child's special education services. If you don't have one, you can ask your public school for an evaluation, but they have up to 45 days to complete it after you give consent. That timeline is important if you’re trying to meet the voucher application deadlines. The money itself comes through what they call education savings accounts, which a company named Odyssey manages digitally. You can use it for tuition, tutoring, transportation, and even school meals. It’s pretty flexible. Now, let's talk about private schools themselves. They have to apply to join the program, too, showing they've been around for at least two years and are accredited. They also need to give nationally recognized exams, but they don't have to use the state's STAAR test that public schools use. This raises questions about accountability and whether we can compare the academic outcomes of students using vouchers versus those in public schools. More than 1,600 private schools have signed up, mostly in big areas like Houston and Dallas-Fort Worth. But here's where things get really sticky with the law. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton recently gave an opinion stating the comptroller can block schools from participating if they’re “illegally tied to terrorists or foreign adversaries.” This came after the comptroller's office asked for guidance regarding schools associated with the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), which Governor Greg Abbott designated a terrorist organization. Now, CAIR has sued Abbott, saying that label is false and defamatory. And here’s another twist: the U.S. State Department doesn't consider CAIR a terrorist group. Because of this opinion, hundreds of schools, including those primarily serving Muslim, Christian, and disabled students, were initially shut out of the program. The comptroller’s office has since said it’s inviting compliant Cognia schools back in groups. This situation brings up major constitutional questions around due process and religious freedom under the First Amendment. Can the state arbitrarily decide who participates based on a label that's disputed and not federally recognized? What about freedom of association for these schools? It's a legal fight that could have far-reaching effects on who gets to participate in state programs and how government agencies wield their power. If you're applying, you'll start getting notifications in April, letting you know if you'll get funding. Then you've got until June 1st to officially enroll your kid in a private school, and the money should hit those education savings accounts in July. So, while it sounds straightforward, this whole voucher rollout is loaded with legal challenges, policy debates about equity, and big questions about the future of education funding in Texas. It's a lot more than just a simple application form. Keep an eye on this one, because the legal battles are probably just beginning.