← Back to Legal News
ICE detentionTexas immigrationhoustontexasimmigrationlegal implicationsdetainee deathslegal-newshuman rights
Texas ICE Facilities Face Legal Scrutiny After Homicide Ruling, Surge in Deaths
Key Takeaways
- •A medical examiner ruled the death of Geraldo Lunas Campos in ICE custody a homicide by asphyxiation, yet no criminal charges have been filed and witnesses were almost deported.
- •ICE facilities in Texas experienced six deaths in six weeks, with multiple cases citing 'medical distress' initially, only to be contradicted by later findings or family suspicions.
- •Camp East Montana, the largest ICE detention center, was rapidly built by an inexperienced contractor and faces widespread allegations of medical neglect, abuse, and critical policy failures regarding force use and sexual assault oversight.
- •Systemic failures include delayed and inconsistent death reporting, destruction of crucial video evidence, and historically poor medical care exacerbated by policy changes, leading to a high rate of 'preventable' deaths according to the ACLU.
- •Despite these issues, the federal government plans to significantly expand detention capacity in Texas, facing local resistance and raising concerns about escalating health risks and strains on community services.
Picture this: you're sitting at a bar, chatting with a friend who's a legal analyst for Ringo Legal. You hear about these shocking incidents, and you're trying to make sense of the legal mess. That’s what we're here to talk about: the grim reality unfolding in Texas immigrant detention centers, particularly after a medical examiner actually called one death a homicide.
It all started with a 911 call last month from an immigration detention center in El Paso. A federal contractor reported a 55-year-old Cuban man, Geraldo Lunas Campos, had 'attempted to hang himself.' The very next day, officials said Lunas Campos had passed away due to 'medical distress.' Sounds straightforward, right? Not so fast. The medical examiner didn't agree. They ruled his death a homicide, stating he died from asphyxiation while being physically restrained by law enforcement personnel. Now, that changes everything.
This isn't just a sad story; it's a huge legal problem. When someone dies in government custody, especially by homicide, it screams for accountability. But here's the kicker: so far, no criminal investigation has really taken off, and no charges have been filed. This case isn't just about Camp East Montana, the tent facility in Fort Bliss where Lunas Campos died. It’s shining a harsh light on conditions across nearly two dozen other ICE detention centers in Texas.
You see, in just six weeks between December and January, six people died in ICE custody right here in Texas. Three of them were at Camp East Montana alone. It started with Francisco Gaspar-Andrés, a 48-year-old Guatemalan man who ICE claimed died from organ failure after a couple of weeks in the hospital. This pattern of deaths, especially with varying explanations, makes you wonder what's really going on behind those walls.
Texas is like the main entry point, the funnel, for the country's immigration control system. It's where the journey often starts, ends, or both. Kristin Etter, who directs policy for the Texas Immigration Law Council, puts it simply: Texas is the 'epicenter' of this system. In February, over 18,700 people were held in Texas ICE facilities. That's the most in the country. Plus, our state sees an average of four deportation flights take off daily, more than anywhere else. We're also seeing a lot more court cases about people being held illegally by ICE, with a big chunk coming from Texas.
Now, let's zoom in on Camp East Montana. It's the largest ICE detention center in the country, holding over 3,000 men and women on a military base. It's supposedly a blueprint for future facilities, which is a scary thought given its history. It was built super fast, in just two months last summer, by a small Virginia company, Acquisition Logistics, that had no prior experience running detention centers. This setup has been a mess since day one. We're talking medical neglect, bad food, dirty conditions. Rights advocates are calling it a 'developing humanitarian crisis.'
More than 45 people held there have reported serious abuse and injuries. One letter to DHS and ICE supervisors mentioned a teenager who said staff threw him to the ground, beat him, and crushed his testicles, all while blocking security cameras. Even ICE's own inspectors found at least 60 violations shortly after the camp opened, including having barely half the promised security staff. DHS did say that claims of 'inhumane' conditions were 'categorically false,' but it's hard to square that with what we're hearing.
What's even more troubling, two officials who saw ICE's investigation report mentioned that the facility didn't even have a policy for when and how contractors could use force. And there was no one assigned to oversee sexual assault complaints, which federal rules require. Contractors only got 40 hours of training, way less than the usual 42 *days* for regular ICE agents. This stuff just screams policy failure and a lack of proper oversight, which can lead straight to rights violations. Acquisition Logistics hasn't said if things have gotten better, which leaves you guessing.
Federal Representative Veronica Escobar, an El Paso Democrat who's visited the camp several times, says things are 'deteriorating rapidly.' After cases of tuberculosis and COVID-19 showed up there, she was told not to enter certain areas because detainees hadn't been tested yet. Few people were even wearing masks. She worries about a massive public health impact on the community if these 'tent cities' prioritize profits over people. She's right to be worried; public health is everyone's business.
Despite all the complaints, Lunas Campos' death is the one that really got people's attention. Six detainees in El Paso told a federal court that Lunas Campos, who had lived in New York for nearly two decades before ICE picked him up, begged for his asthma medicine for days. They said staff refused and threatened him with solitary confinement. After being dragged to isolation, shackled, witnesses heard a thud and then his gasping for air. Then, silence. Chris Benoit, the lawyer for Lunas Campos' kids, says they just want the truth and accountability for their dad's death. It’s a basic right, right?
Local and federal prosecutors haven't said if they'll file criminal charges, even with the homicide ruling. Experts say state prosecutors *can* bring charges even if a death happens on military property, which is usually federal jurisdiction. The investigation is still internal, which makes you wonder about transparency.
The government even tried to deport the detainees who witnessed Lunas Campos' final moments. A federal judge in Texas had to step in and block that. Benoit says no one even knows where those six witnesses are now, which is a massive concern for due process and ensuring justice. Then, ICE quietly changed Lunas Campos' cause of death in public reports, calling it 'spontaneous use of force' to keep him from harming himself. Claire Trickler-McNulty, a former senior ICE official, said it was the first homicide death involving ICE staff she could remember in 15 years. Scott Shuchart, who used to be a policy chief at ICE, said deaths from staff violence are 'another level' and totally 'preventable.' That means training and oversight failed.
Eleven days after Lunas Campos died, 36-year-old Victor Manuel Díaz from Nicaragua became the third person to die in six weeks at the El Paso camp. The 911 call was similar: someone tried to kill themselves, found with pants around their neck. But here's where it gets murky again: Díaz's body went to an army hospital, not the local medical examiner's office, and the army won't release the autopsy. His family doesn't believe it was suicide, which again puts the spotlight on transparency and proper investigation.
Many of the nine people who've died in Texas ICE centers since the second Trump term were in their mid-forties. While ICE often says these deaths are from natural causes, many investigations are still open, and autopsies often aren't made public. Take Tien Xuan Phan, a 55-year-old Vietnamese man who died last July at the Karnes County facility. ICE said he had seizures and vomiting. Eight months later, the Bexar County prosecutor's office still won't release his autopsy, citing a 'pending' federal investigation.
Congress has set strict rules for reporting deaths in ICE custody: relevant details should go public within two days, and full reports within 90 days. But under the current administration, these reports are often delayed. Lunas Campos’ case is a prime example: ICE waited nearly a week before saying he died of difficulties. Only after the medical examiner talked to his family about a possible homicide did ICE then suggest it was a suicide attempt, and then later, that it was due to force. This shifting narrative erodes trust.
Angélica César from Human Rights Watch argues that independent authorities should investigate these deaths and perform autopsies. That kind of process, she says, 'would protect both families and the integrity of the investigation.' The ACLU even found in a 2024 report that ICE often doesn't even have clear rules on how or when to do autopsies. They didn't order one for Ronald Cruz, a 39-year-old Honduran, until his family offered to pay. It turned out he died of bacterial meningitis, which experts believe could have been treated. This points to a severe systemic failure in medical care and record-keeping.
Lawyers and whistleblowers say that ICE sometimes doesn't keep evidence crucial for investigating deaths. Civil lawsuits have even shown facility officials destroying relevant video recordings. This happened with Gourgen Mirimanian, a 54-year-old Armenian man who died in 2018. Parts of security footage from his last hours were reportedly unclear, and other 'crucial' videos weren't saved. At Camp East Montana, authorities are refusing to share video tied to Lunas Campos' death. This isn't just bad practice; it hints at potential obstruction of justice.
Complaints about abuse and bad medical care in ICE detention aren't new, but officials say conditions under this administration have become even more deadly. Historically, many deaths were likely preventable with better medical attention. The ACLU looked at 52 deaths between 2017 and 2021 and concluded that 49 of them were 'probably preventable,' mostly due to wrong diagnoses. And in 40% of cases, ICE staff didn't provide timely medical care. This is alarming, especially as detention numbers are soaring.
Things are reportedly worse at places like the South Texas Family Residential Center in Dilley. You might have seen photos of 5-year-old Liam Conejo Ramos after his detention there last month, which went viral. Now, over 1,300 parents and kids are at that center. Faisal Al-Juburi, from the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (RAICES), says there have been over 1,000 complaints about poor medical care since the center reopened last April. And last month, they confirmed at least two measles cases there.
Representative Joaquín Castro of San Antonio brought up a two-month-old baby with bronchitis who was hospitalized after choking on his own vomit, then suddenly deported with his family despite efforts to stop it. Castro called it 'monstrous' and promised to demand answers. DHS, however, said the mother 'chose to bring her child into custody with her' and 'enter and remain in the country illegally.' This shows a stark difference in how government agencies and advocates view the human element in these situations.
Lawyers describe Dilley's conditions as having undrinkable water, almost no schooling, and people forced to sleep under fluorescent lights. This aligns with an ongoing lawsuit trying to stop the administration from ending a decades-old agreement, the Flores Settlement, which protects minors in detention. Even seriously ill people, like a 6-year-old with leukemia, apparently get minimal treatment. Brian Todd, a spokesperson for CoreCivic, which runs Dilley, denies claims of poor care, saying their staff works hard and provides 'comprehensive care at all hours.' He also calls reports of undrinkable water 'categorically false.' But the constant flow of complaints paints a different picture.
At the Prairieland Detention Center near Dallas, Leqaa Kordia, a 33-year-old woman arrested after a Gaza protest, was hospitalized this month after falling in the bathroom. She described 'filthy' conditions that made her sick, and the fall led to a seizure. Her lawyers say she was chained to a hospital bed for days, and her family didn't even know where she was. This raises serious questions about humane treatment and communication during medical emergencies. Travis Fife from the Texas Civil Rights Project warns that these 'cramped and inhumane' conditions could become a 'civil rights disaster,' affecting even pregnant women, cancer patients, and people with severe disabilities.
The ICE Health Service Corps is supposed to give medical care, but they only directly provide it in a small number of facilities. Most immigrants are in centers where private, for-profit companies provide the care. And recently, more ICE health workers have quit, saying they're concerned about the quality of care they can actually give. Charlotte Weiss, a lawyer in El Paso, says poor care forces immigrants into an impossible choice: stay in the U.S. and suffer, or give up and go back to danger just to get out. That's not a real choice.
Despite all these problems, the Trump administration wants to open even more ICE facilities in warehouses across Texas and the country to hold even more people. Several existing centers were already full last year. With almost 4 million immigration court cases pending, the government wants more space, or they're trying to push people to leave on their own – they've offered $2,600 to those who voluntarily depart. After a recent Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling upheld a Trump policy denying bond to detained immigrants, many in Texas will stay locked up for years during their deportation process, unless they give up and go back home. This policy significantly restricts the constitutional right to seek bail, effectively punishing individuals for pursuing legal avenues.
Some cities are pushing back against this expansion. Residents in Hutchins, near Dallas, strongly opposed a plan to lease a warehouse there that would hold more migrants than the town's entire population. The property owner ended up pulling out of the deal with ICE. In El Paso County, there's a plan for a facility that could hold 8,500 people, but local officials are trying to block it. There are also at least two more planned for McAllen and San Antonio. In San Antonio, Representative Tony Gonzales, a Republican, claimed it would create 'good-paying jobs,' but the mayor, Gina Ortiz Jones, called for more transparency and disagreed.
Representative Escobar says that if the administration keeps expanding detention capacity, these growing problems in El Paso are just a preview. It won't just be bad 'for the people in custody,' she says, 'but for the communities that will have to deal with the health risks, the strain on their emergency services, and the impact on their hospitals.' Expanding this problem quickly, she warns, 'will be a nightmare.' It's a clear warning about public policy decisions having ripple effects that stretch far beyond the detention center walls, impacting local governments, public health systems, and the fundamental rights of individuals.
Original source: Texas State Government: Governor, Legislature & Policy Coverage.
