← Back to Legal News
Higher Education TexasImmigration LawState Powerlegal-newsTexas H-1BimmigrationhoustontexasGreg Abbott
Texas Gov. Abbott's H-1B Visa Freeze: A Deep Dive into State Power, Federal Law, and the Future of Texas Talent
Key Takeaways
- •Governor Abbott’s order restricts Texas public entities, not private companies, from initiating new H-1B visa applications without state approval.
- •H-1B visas are a federal immigration matter, prompting legal challenges to the extent of a state governor's authority to impose such a ban on state-funded institutions.
- •The freeze targets highly specialized positions like researchers and physicians, potentially causing a 'brain drain' as talent may seek opportunities in other states or countries.
- •H-1B visas are highly regulated federally, requiring competitive wages and disproving common accusations of widespread fraud or cheap labor exploitation.
Alright, so let's talk about something pretty significant happening in Texas right now, especially if you care about our universities, hospitals, or just the state's economic standing. Governor Greg Abbott just dropped an order that’s got a lot of people scratching their heads and some folks pretty worried. He’s told all public universities and state agencies to stop bringing in new workers on H-1B visas. This isn’t just a policy tweak; it’s a big move with some serious legal and economic ripples.
Think about it this way: the Governor, in a radio chat, basically said he doesn’t see why taxpayer-funded places should have foreign workers. So, he put a temporary hold, a freeze, on state-run institutions from starting new H-1B visa applications. This freeze is set to last until the end of the next legislative session, which is May 31, 2027. And get this, if they want to apply for one, they now need special written permission from the Texas Workforce Commission. It's a whole new layer of bureaucracy where there wasn't one before.
Now, you might be wondering, what exactly are H-1B visas? Well, they’re nonimmigrant visas, a specific kind that lets U.S. employers hire people from outside the country for highly specialized jobs. We're talking about folks in medical fields, engineering, advanced research – jobs where you need a bachelor's degree at least, often more. Congress set these up way back in 1990. There’s a cap on how many the federal government can give out each year: 65,000 generally, plus another 20,000 for people with master’s degrees from U.S. universities. But here's a kicker, and it's a big one for our state: public institutions, like our universities, usually aren't subject to that federal cap. They've been able to recruit top talent without going through the super competitive lottery system private companies face.
Experts will tell you that the people these visas bring in are doing highly specialized work. Their skill sets are often tough to find here in the U.S. When you put a stop to this, even just for state entities, it creates a real problem. Faye Kolly, an immigration attorney in Austin, pretty much summed it up: these folks might have to pack up and leave, or look for work in another state. That means our top universities, the ones we're so proud of, might struggle to attract the brightest minds. Why would someone come to Texas when they could go to 49 other states, or even another country, without this kind of roadblock?
So, who really feels the pinch from this order? The freeze only hits public universities and state agencies when they want to bring in *new* H-1B workers. We’re talking about researchers, professors, doctors, and engineers. It doesn't immediately affect people who are already working here on an H-1B or have an application already in the pipeline. But here’s the rub: once their current visa runs out, they'll likely need to apply for a new one. And that's when they'll hit this new wall. The Governor's order is a little vague, too. Lawyers like Jason Finkelman, an Austin-based immigration attorney, aren't even sure if an H-1B holder at one Texas public university could easily switch to another without hitting a snag from this freeze. It just adds a huge layer of uncertainty.
Let’s put some numbers to this. Texas has a massive workforce, almost 16 million people. Over 40,000 of them work here on H-1B visas. Most of those are in big private companies like Cognizant Technology Solutions or Infosys. But even though H-1B workers at public universities are a small fraction of the total workforce – less than 1% at places like Texas A&M, UT Southwestern Medical Center, and MD Anderson Cancer Center – their impact is anything but small. These institutions are major research hubs and medical centers. Imagine if UT Southwestern, with its 228 H-1B workers, or MD Anderson, with 171, suddenly can’t replace their specialized staff.
Now, for the big legal question: Does Governor Abbott even have the power to do this? Immigration policy, by its very nature, is a federal deal. Congress makes the rules. States don't usually get to mess with the H-1B system directly. So, what Abbott is doing isn't a direct freeze on the *entire* H-1B visa system; it's a freeze on *Texas public institutions* from applying. This is where things get really murky. Finkelman, the attorney, isn't convinced the state government’s authority over public universities stretches far enough to enforce this kind of hiring ban. How would he enforce it? He could try to withhold funding from universities that don’t play ball, or perhaps try to oversee all their hiring decisions. We saw the state’s power over public universities grow recently with Senate Bill 37, which trimmed faculty influence on academic choices. So, there’s a precedent for the state tightening its grip.
The consequences of this freeze could be pretty stark. Individuals are already worried about losing their jobs in Texas. Employers are concerned their skilled workers will just pick up and go to another state once their visas run out. Think about it: If you're a brilliant researcher or professor, and Texas makes it harder for you to work here, you're not going to sit around. You'll go to California, New York, or Boston – places that are still actively recruiting. Finkelman put it bluntly: “Those researchers and professors are just going to go to other US universities.” This means Texas could lose out on critical talent, impacting our standing in higher education and research. It’s a classic brain drain scenario, and it doesn't just hurt the universities; it hurts the state's long-term innovation and economic growth.
You might have heard some talk about H-1B visas being 'exploited' or used for 'cheap labor.' But honestly, that's not what the experts are seeing. Finkelman, who works with these visas daily, says the H-1B is actually one of the *most regulated* visas in our whole immigration system. There are strict rules. For example, employers have to file a labor condition application that basically locks them into paying a competitive minimum wage, set by the U.S. Department of Labor. Plus, they have to tell current employees that an H-1B applicant is being hired and what their wage will be. Most employers would rather hire American workers if they could, simply because it’s cheaper and less complex. But they turn to H-1B visas because they genuinely can't find folks in the U.S. with the exact, specific skills they need for these jobs. So, claims of widespread fraud? He's just not seeing it.
Ultimately, this isn't just about a few dozen or even a few hundred visas. It's about a fundamental clash between state executive power and federal immigration law. It's about Texas's reputation as a hub for innovation and specialized talent. It's about the ability of our premier educational and medical institutions to compete globally. The next few years, leading up to that May 2027 deadline, are going to be really telling. We'll see if this order stands up to legal scrutiny and what its true, lasting impact will be on the Lone Star State.
Original source: Texas State Government: Governor, Legislature & Policy Coverage.
