← Back to Legal News
Judge Blocks Camp Mystic Changes to Preserve Flood Evidence Amid Lawsuit
Key Takeaways
- •A Travis County District Court judge issued an order blocking Camp Mystic from altering flood-damaged property.
- •The primary legal purpose of the order is to preserve potential evidence for a pending wrongful death lawsuit.
- •Specifically, cabins, grounds, and other key buildings affected by the July 4th flood on the Guadalupe River cannot be demolished, repaired, or reconstructed.
- •The order stems from a wrongful death case filed by the parents of camper Cile Steward, whose body has not been recovered.
- •The camp's Cypress Lake portion, where cabins did not flood, is not covered by the order and may reopen this summer.
Alright, let's talk about what's happening with Camp Mystic, that summer camp down by the Guadalupe River. You might remember the tragedy last summer, when a massive flood hit on July 4th. Twenty-seven girls and the camp's executive director lost their lives. Now, a judge in Austin has stepped in with a pretty big ruling.
Basically, the camp can't touch the areas that were hit hard by the flood. That means no tearing down, no fixing up, and no rebuilding a bunch of cabins where campers were sleeping when the water came in. Travis County District Court Judge Maya Guerra Gamble made that call. It's all about making sure evidence is kept safe while a lawsuit moves forward.
Think about it like this: if you're trying to figure out exactly what happened somewhere, you wouldn't want anyone to clean up or change the scene, right? That's what's going on here. The camp's grounds, its main office, the recreation hall, and the commissary — all these spots are important in the ongoing wrongful death case. Cile Steward, one of the campers, is still missing, and her parents are the ones who filed this suit.
Now, this order isn't a total shutdown. The judge did say Camp Mystic can still open its neighboring Cypress Lake camp site this summer. That's the part where the cabins didn't flood. The attorneys are working on drawing a clear line on a map, showing exactly where the restricted Guadalupe portion ends and the Cypress Lake portion begins. So, some parts of the camp will see kids this summer.
CiCi Steward, Cile's mother, told reporters this ruling feels like a huge win. She said it's important to them to keep the evidence intact so they can truly understand what happened to their children. It's about getting answers.
Mikal Watts, who's representing Camp Mystic and the Eastland family, the owners, also agreed with the judge's decision. He said she did the right thing by making sure the evidence along the Guadalupe River is preserved. So, on that front, both sides seem to agree.
When you were in the courtroom, you'd have seen a pretty clear division. Camp Mystic supporters wore green shirts and buttons on one side. On the other, you had the parents and families of the girls who died, many wearing buttons with smiling pictures of their daughters. It was a really emotional scene. CiCi Steward wore a hummingbird brooch, telling everyone it's a symbol of her connection with Cile.
This hearing was the first time everyone came together in court to debate what went down that night, who might be at fault, and what needs to happen next. Bradley Beckworth, the Stewards' attorney, made it clear he wants to know every detail: what happened in each cabin, how high the water got, what records existed. He even argued that some evidence might have been lost or cleaned up already.
Beckworth showed a picture of Cile — freckle-faced, smiling by the water, her hair blowing. He described her as maternal, bright, athletic, a dancer, someone who loved animals. A woman in the audience visibly broke down, trying to hold back tears. He put it simply: "When you're talking about children, nothing could be more important than figuring out what happened."
Watts, for Camp Mystic, talked about the practical side. The camp has already signed up over 800 kids for this summer. They're looking at nearly $3 million in tuition if they can't open at all. He also mentioned that the Christian camp believes it has an important ministry to continue. They hope to eventually build new cabins on higher ground behind the flooded Guadalupe River area. Dick Eastland, the camp's founder, died trying to save campers that night.
The judge's decision came after she wrapped up testimony from Edward Eastland, Dick's son and the Guadalupe camp's director. He was the only witness called and had a tough time answering quick questions about the camp's evacuation plans, records, and what his family was doing that night.
After a brief break and conferring with the attorneys, Judge Gamble came back with her instructions. "I want to thank you all for trusting me to make this decision," she said. "Obviously this is a very difficult time for many, many people, most especially the parents. And I feel that. I know it is difficult for everyone, and I feel that as well." It's clear this isn't just a legal case; it's deeply personal for everyone involved.
