← Back to Legal News
legal-newshousing-discriminationHUD InvestigationhoustonProperty RightsReligious DiscriminationFair Housing ActTexas Lawtexas
Feds Open Fair Housing Probe into North Texas Development, Raising Due Process Questions
Key Takeaways
- •HUD launched an investigation into The Meadow development for alleged religious or national origin discrimination under the Fair Housing Act.
- •Developers are claiming "due process concerns," arguing that repeated federal investigations, after prior state and federal probes closed, appear politically motivated.
- •Prominent Texas officials, including Governor Greg Abbott and Attorney General Ken Paxton, have actively opposed the project and supported the federal intervention.
- •The case highlights a legal tension between federal anti-discrimination laws, developers' property rights, and the potential impact of political pressure on enforcement actions.
Hey, let's talk about something big happening up north of Dallas that really gets into some touchy legal stuff. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, or HUD, is now digging into a planned community there, looking at whether it discriminated against people because of their religion or where they came from.
This whole thing centers on a place called The Meadow. It used to be known as the East Plano Islamic Center City. It's supposed to have over a thousand homes, a mosque, a K-12 school, and some shops, all pretty close to Josephine. The developers, EPIC Real Properties, Inc., and Community Capital Partners, apparently marketed it to Muslims. That’s where the trouble started.
See, a while back, some state officials accused the folks behind this project of religious discrimination. It even led to the Texas Workforce Commission (TWC) doing its own investigation. They actually closed that one out last September after reaching an agreement with the developers. And the U.S. Justice Department quietly closed its own look into the project, saying the developers promised to follow fair housing rules.
So, you might be thinking, "Why is HUD getting involved now if others already finished their investigations?" Good question. HUD Secretary Scott Turner announced their probe after the TWC filed a new complaint, alleging a "large-scale pattern of religious discriminatory conduct" by The Meadow's developers.
This is where it gets legally messy. The developers for The Meadow say they've followed all the rules. A lawyer for one of them, Eric Hudson, even pointed out that they sued the TWC just to make sure that state investigation formally closed. Then, boom, HUD announces its own new investigation. Hudson thinks that whole chain of events raises some serious due process concerns. He's basically saying it looks less like neutral enforcement and more like someone trying to find a new legal arena once the state had to defend itself in court. It's a classic legal maneuver argument: "Are they just forum shopping for a win?"
This isn't the first time this project has been under the microscope. Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Attorney General Ken Paxton have been vocal opponents. You’ve seen other state agencies investigate, and Paxton’s office even has a lawsuit going against it. U.S. Senator John Cornyn asked the Justice Department to get involved, too. It’s no secret that opposition to Islam has become a talking point for some state Republicans.
Governor Abbott even applauded HUD’s new investigation, taking credit for pushing the initial state probe. He didn’t mince words, saying he hoped the investigation would stop the project entirely. He said, "The Meadow will remain just that — an empty field." Now, that’s a pretty strong statement from a state leader about a housing development.
From a public policy standpoint, this whole situation pits several things against each other. You've got federal fair housing laws, which protect against discrimination based on religion or national origin. Then you've got property development rights. And, frankly, you have the political influence of state leaders shaping the narrative and pushing for specific outcomes. If you're a developer, you have a right to "due process," meaning you shouldn't be endlessly investigated after previous probes close, especially if it seems politically motivated. This case will really test how those protections hold up when there's a lot of public and political heat.
Just a few weeks before this, HUD actually closed another big investigation here in Texas. They looked into how the state handled Hurricane Harvey aid and found no reasonable cause to believe there was discrimination. So, they can close cases without finding fault. We’ll have to wait and see how this one plays out. But it’s definitely a situation that could set some precedents for future developments, especially those tied to specific communities or faiths.
Original source: Texas State Government: Governor, Legislature & Policy Coverage.
